Plain Pizza pie is so good, staff are nice! I just moved here from NJ/NY and it’s the only pizza place that taste this good in the area. We’ll be back!!

Hands down the BEST pepperoni and sausage pizza i've ever had. I don't order from them as much as i should, but when i do, it's even better than i remember. Gonna try and get another this month, and you should too !😋

Moved to area a couple years ago, first time visiting Americas Pie. Great staff, great service. I tried a special they had, the Drunken Ceaser sandwich. WOW. Might be best sandwich I’ve ever had. Will be coming back to check out their other unique options.

The cashier was a lovely lady that was wonderfully warm and helpful. They have a pretty extensive menu and I had no idea what I wanted. I was given great advice and treated like a an old friend. I was in town for work so this friendly service was such a nice warm welcome. Not only do I want to go back for the fantastic food, but the service is also a big part of why I want to go back and try more menu options.

Never a bad meal. Always hot fresh and delicious

EXCELLENT customer service. There was a small error in our order (it happens, nobody is perfect). We were asked to fill out a survey and mentioned it. We got a call from the manager immediately and she more than remedied it! The food is always excellent. We would have been back anyway, but will definitely always be loyal customers!

Trust anything and everything on their menu, no matter the combination. Please. It’s all so well-made and people deserve to know about them. Phenomenal food that’s no more expensive than others, if not better pricing than most other joints especially out of WC. Order from here for a plethora of food, all beautiful stuff. Great group running the place and working there

Updating this review 9 years later to remind everyone that America’s pie is still awesome

I had a large catering order for my mom’s birthday. Everything was top notch! Chicken Parm and cheese steak eggrolls were the fan favorites! When I ordered over the phone I had the flu. My brother picked up the order on the day of the party and they asked how I was feeling - so sweet!!! Thank you for making our event great.

Each time I have ordered anything from here, absolutely delicious!!

Built my own salad. It was probably best salad I have ever eaten in my life. Generous portions and fresh ingredients. Highly recommend.

I've only ordered catering from here and the pasta and chicken cutlets are excellent. I also have to give them a big shout out for being so accommodating when 6 out of our group of 13 got the flu and I asked to cancel our food order only 3 hours before pickup. They were great!! Definitely looking forward to ordering again once the whole group can get together again.

This was the second or third time we have ordered from the Essington store. One of the best hoagies I have ever had. The delivery was quick and friendly. Out new go to on the Island

America’s Pie is one of our go-to’s and favorites in West Chester. The food is always exceptional. I recently tried their catering for my staff’s holiday party after searching for options in the area and WOW, they did not disappoint! Catering menu selection is huge and they are so super friendly and easy to work with. The charcuterie tray was next level, and food arrived hot and everything was SO good!! And their desserts were amazing, too! We love America’s Pie and always highly recommend!

Had them cater my wedding and the food was absolutely amazing! Everyone was raving about how great the food was! Stopped in their pizzeria and ordered a couple apps and couple sandwiches, that food was incredible as well! I’d also like to add that the service was quick, employees were extremely nice, and helpful. All around fantastic experience!

Tasty pizza and stromboli.

Bruh, pizza like this deserves the world. I don't need to write a million word review.... We stopped in because it was near The Bates and we were in love with the pizza. The inside gives a old school gas station feel. It's a vibe. I like it. Service; well they took the order, made the food, gave the food all with a smile so yeah, well done. But $22for a pie was a bit steep.

Great place! Our business orders lunch from them a few times a month and the sandwiches are incredible! You can tell that they care about their menu and offer some unique options.

Excellent gluten free choices for my celiac son! It's so convenient to order delivery or take out, or just stop in and eat. very friendly staff. pizza is on the cheesier side, i prefer more sauce myself. but wings are delicious, onion rings, and appetizers. Delivery drivers are really excellent.

Most delicious pizza my son and I had in a while. Definitely recommend the pizza with pepperoni.

Absolutely amazing! America’s Pie in West Chester never disappoints. The food is always fresh, delicious, and packed with flavor. The staff is friendly, welcoming, and on point every single time. Whether it’s pizza, sandwiches, or something new off the menu, it’s always top-notch.

They also go above and beyond when it comes to supporting local community sports—something that means so much to families like ours. Thank you from all of us Hilltop 12UB moms! We’re so grateful for everything you do. Highly recommend—if you haven’t tried it yet, you seriously don’t know what you’re missing!

OMG the delivery driver was AJAZING she brought it to my back yard (we didn't ask for it) I going to give her more of a tip!

I have never had a bad meal here! The menu is huge so I always get something different each time and everything I have gotten has been so delicious!

We love America’s Pie in Tinicum! The staff is incredibly nice and accommodating. You-got-it type energy. All tips go right to the staff. Always greeted like a friend when you walk in. They appreciate and thank you for being a customer. Overall, great energy. And the food??? Always hot, fresh, and delicious! The Jay Wright is award-worthy. Phenomenal. 6 out of 5 stars, highly recommend.

The flank steak tacos and bang bang mango habanero tacos are amazing.

Normal price for pizza but twice the size slices!! Not too thick but not thin crust. Been there 2 times, I'll be going again!!

We ordered from here yesterday at work. Was my first time and I had the Philly special hands down the best sandwich I ever had. I have eaten at hundreds of places. Will be going back for sure

America’s Pie is a favorite place for us to get a take out meal. The food is great. Menu choices are great. Service is great. Quantity is great. Love this place!

One of my favorite pizza places. I have Celiac disease and ate delicious pizza that was safe with no cross contact! This place is sooooo good i had a dream about their pizza after eating it.

Can't really complain about a free slice! First time trying anything from there. It was good! I will be back to explore the menu!